See what Halloween costumes Jonathan, Drew, Justine and Jenna pick out for each other. Which one is your favorite? Let us know in the comments below!

Get vintage inspired Halloween costume ideas with Retrostage! Outfits include: 1950s Cruella, Pin-up Witch, 1940s Poison Ivy, and 1960s Angel.

Instead of going the scary and spooky route, add a regal touch to your Halloween get-up Stephanie Petit is a Royals Editor, Writer and Reporter at PEOPLE. Yes, it's fun to channel fictional characters ...